A Singapore court has upheld a $490.32 million arbitral award in favor of Kleros Capital Partners, rejecting Tata Power’s appeal over a failed Russian coal mining joint venture. The decision by the Singapore International Commercial Court (SICC) confirms the 2023 ruling, which found that Tata Power violated confidentiality agreements and acted in bad faith during negotiations for the Krutogorovo deposit project.
How Tata Power allegedly misused confidential data
The conflict traces back to 2013, when Kleros approached Tata Power for partnership in the Russian coal venture. The firms signed non-disclosure agreements while Kleros shared proprietary data about the project’s geological potential, operational plans, and licensing requirements. By 2018, Tata Power’s Russian subsidiary, FENR, had independently secured the mining license and later abandoned the project in 2022, citing financial concerns. Kleros initiated arbitration in 2020 under the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC) rules, accusing Tata Power of misleading conduct during negotiations.
The arbitral tribunal delivered its unanimous decision in September 2023, determining that Tata Power had breached its contractual obligations. In July 2025, the majority of the tribunal valued the coal project at $1.0215 billion. Determining that Kleros had lost a 60 percent chance of successfully developing the resource, the majority ordered Tata Power to pay $490.32 million in damages. This figure was supplemented by approximately $8.29 million in legal costs and an annual interest rate of 5.33 percent. A dissenting arbitrator, AK Ganguli, argued for significantly lower damages—$13.5 million—claiming Tata Power’s actions did not prevent Kleros from independently pursuing the project.
The SICC dismissed Tata Power’s appeal on two key points: procedural deficiencies and claims of arbitrator bias. The company argued the tribunal had not properly addressed legal issues such as causation and the remoteness of damages. The court ruled that arbitral awards need only address essential legal questions, not every possible argument. Regarding bias, Tata Power pointed to connections between Kleros’ litigation funder, Omni Bridgeway, and two arbitrators in unrelated cases. The SICC found these links too indirect to establish a real risk of partiality.
Singapore court reaffirms arbitration’s finality and integrity
Singapore’s legal system intervenes in arbitral awards only under narrow, exceptional circumstances, such as demonstrable breaches of natural justice or clear evidence of arbitrator bias. This approach reinforces the city-state’s position as a predictable and reliable seat for international commercial arbitration, where final decisions are upheld barring severe procedural failures. The ruling reflects Singapore’s commitment to maintaining the integrity of arbitration as a dispute resolution mechanism.
In this instance, the SICC determined that no such failure had occurred. The bench found that Tata Power’s arguments failed to meet these rigorous thresholds, treating the challenge instead as an attempt to re-litigate the merits of the underlying dispute.
The dispute originated from agreements signed in 2013 and 2014, when Tata Power and Kleros discussed forming a joint venture for the Krutogorovo coal deposit. As negotiations progressed, disagreements arose over equity stakes and control, leading Tata Power to pursue the project independently. The company acquired the mining license in January 2018 but later abandoned the venture in 2022 due to financial challenges. Kleros filed for arbitration in November 2020, alleging that Tata Power had used confidential information to secure the license without Kleros’ involvement.